For Reviewers

(IJLPE) appreciates the valuable contribution of all reviewers and their expertise to the International Journal of Law and Psychology Education (IJLPE). Their invaluable input helps maintain the high-quality standards of our publication. To ensure consistency and clarity in the review process, (IJLPE) has compiled a comprehensive set of guidelines for your reference.

Confidentiality

Please treat the manuscript and its contents as confidential. Do not share or discuss any part of the manuscript with anyone other than the editor unless explicitly authorized. If you suspect a conflict of interest or need assistance, please contact the editor immediately.

Objectivity

Provide objective and constructive feedback, avoiding personal biases or opinions. Focus on the manuscript's content, structure, and relevance to the journal's scope.

Timeliness

Please complete your review within the specified time frame, typically three to four weeks. If you anticipate any delays or require an extension, inform the editor as soon as possible.

Review Structure

Your review should include the following sections:

  1. Summary: Provide a brief overview of the manuscript, highlighting its main objectives, methods, and findings.
  2. Evaluation: Assess the manuscript's overall quality, originality, and significance to the field.
  3. Recommendations: Suggest improvements in the areas of research design, methodology, data analysis, presentation, or interpretation of results.
  4. Final Recommendation: Based on your evaluation, recommend one of the following actions: accept, accept with minor revisions, accept with major revisions, or reject.

Detailed Feedback

Address the following aspects in your review:

  1. Title: Evaluate the title's appropriateness and clarity.
  2. Abstract: Assess the abstract's completeness and accuracy in summarizing the manuscript.
  3. Introduction: Comment on the background, problem statement, objectives, and research question.
  4. Literature Review: Evaluate the thoroughness, relevance, and organization of the cited sources.
  5. Methodology: Assess the research design, sample, data collection methods, and data analysis techniques.
  6. Results: Examine the accuracy, clarity, and appropriateness of the reported findings.
  7. Discussion: Evaluate the interpretation of the results, implications, and contributions to the field.
  8. Conclusion: Comment on the clarity, completeness, and relevance of the conclusion.
  9. References: Check the accuracy, completeness, and formatting of the references.

Ethical Considerations

If you suspect any ethical issues, such as plagiarism, data fabrication, or improper authorship, please report your concerns to the editor immediately.

Final Remarks

Please submit your review through the journal's online submission system. Be sure to include any additional comments or concerns in the designated section.

(IJLPE) appreciates your commitment to the review process and the contribution to the advancement of knowledge in Law and Psychology Education innovation. Your feedback is invaluable in helping authors improve their manuscripts and ensuring the publication of high-quality research.